Friday, October 12, 2007

All dead... or not?!

On the 4th of October, I entered the little dingy room, peered through my thick-rimmed glasses and surveyed the damage. I realized just how many casualties there were... Oh no. This is disastrous, I said to myself, as I absorbed all the gory images around me...


Oh nooooooooooooo....!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Courtesy of heroic SEAB educators.

Through more detailed supervision, Mr Fong realized that some of them were still alive. Arms moving painfully, slowly and weakly, they flailed their arms rather agonizingly, signalling that they were still alive, but Mr Fong knew they would still die soon.


The air stank of decomposition, and Mr Fong retched as he approached the 'war zone'. A wave of sadness and tiredness swept over him as he noted the casualties, and he, still reeling from the smell, picked up the paper (well, he thought it was a death cert, but...) and realized there were, OMG...Maths questions on the paper!


As Mr Fong read through and studied all the death certs papers, he realized most of it were left blank. A certain question 37 had done the trick, for he realized that the rest of the questions were ignored. On the contrary, question 37 was littered with random workings and doodles, and rants like "Wah lau, so freaking difficult la!" and "I am so freaking stupid laaaaaa!" (except they did not use freaking).


To his utter surprise, he read some papers that gave him a jolt on the fateful question 37, as written on those papers were: "I should have gone for the freaking Eatyourmaths sessions!!!!!" Well, this time they really did use 'freaking' (right).


As Mr Fong finished observing the debris and rubble strewn around in the classroom, he gently wiped his spectacles, and also tears of sadness. He concluded that he MUST do an analysis for this massacre- the PSLE Maths paper, to help other batches avoid this massacre (you all know Mr Fong is how patriotic.)

*

[...]

PSLE Maths is a comparative study. This means that your score is not your own score, but a Transformed Score. (For example, if you were lucky and studied hard, you would get the score of Megatron, the big scary Transformer.)


Your scores are compared using the bell curve, and this is also judged by the range, or standard deviation, of the scores. This means that assuming you are of an OK standard, have done Mr Fong's Eatyourmaths worksheets with great care, devotion and love, any question that you find difficult, will be as difficult to all of the rest.


Therefore, you will NOT lose out in this study when you find an abnormally hard question. Reason being, the majority are not able to answer it too! This is how the bell curve works- you will not lose out, unless you are aiming for a 293 score in PSLE to better the previous record.


Therefore, it is important to remember that for future exams, be it PSLE, O-Levels or A-Levels etc, do what you are sure you can do. This will give you an advantage over those who gets stuck at a crazy question, and do not finish what they can actually do.


Do what you can do, and do not waste time moping over what you definitely cannot do, for PSLE is a speed test! Any moping, crying or sleeping is heavily penalized as you will definitely lose marks for not finishing the paper.

[...]

*

Mr Fong wiped his eyes again on his sleeve, gazed sadly at the numerous casualties and after a few 'minutes of silence', grumbled, "Am I a Maths tutor or ICU staff?! Am I here to teach, or to resuscitate PSLE victims who fall blindly to the same tricks (both mathematically and mentally) every year?"

*


(Writer's Note: Till now, Mr Fong still does not know whether his future lies in the classroom or the ambulance.)

34 comments:

daphne maia said...

i think this whole crying over the PSLE math paper thing is... nuts. seriously. if everyone is crying... then u don't cry lah! cos they will moderate what.

in any case. feeling so depressed after an exam is not healthy. parents n teachers are at fault for this ... phenomenon.

daphne maia said...

another thing is that i find that the pri sch education sys here is very unhealthy. which is why i plan to homeschool my kids til they are ready to go to sec sch.

note that homeschool does not mean that they will not get chances to socialize. they will. just not in the local pri schs.

Sam Chan said...

Hi Winston,

This is an interesting post-mortem.

“Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts.” - Winston Churchill

Let's Acquire Wisdom and Live with Passion

mr fong said...

Daphne, for your first point: Agreed! Most insist on their kids getting 100, and this works against the kid in fact for when he does not know 1 question, he gets stressed up and his levels drop yet further.

As for your second point: I have no kids so I can't make a fair statement ;p But it is obvious that I agree that the education here has its unhealthy points. Learning is hardly a bed or roses here.

Thank you for your valuable views!!!!

mr fong said...

Hi Sam, thank you for the quote, how do you find them so well? :-) Yes, indeed it has been one of my more subtle yet incisive 'post-mortems'.

This post-mortem was inspired by the spate of complaints by many different parents about the PSLE Maths paper, on the online and newspaper forums.

Thanks again for coming in the first place, and thanks for the quote and kind words! :D

Sam Rocks!

Bobby said...

I hated the way math was taught to me in school. In America, we are taught to plug numbers into formulas.

This is a method that seems to work best for left-brained individuals.

I asked questions of my teachers they couldn't answer.

I was taught the quadratic equation. I asked my teacher to explain how the equation was derived so I would gain a level of understanding not depending on a "formula". She said it was beyond my scope of intellect.

The truth is, she was simply unable to answer the question.

I am an extremely right brained person and I have to have an application (such as word oriented math problems) in order to understand it. It makes no sense to me to learn anything without application.

Thanks Mr. Fong!!!!!!!!

mr fong said...

Bobby, you are right about your brain composition, I sensed as much from your posts, hehe ;p

Yeah, this post is less of an inquest into PSLE, but more of a satirical piece about the state of our students and their mental strength, and this satire also revolves around the parents who complain without knowing about how PSLE really works.

Thanks for coming and sharing! Actually, quadratic is v easy for your teacher to open up, just open the brackets and square accordingly would be ok already... ;p

Blog Author Ann Clemmons said...

This is hilarious Winston! I think you've got to be doing a great job of getting your students attention, which means you're halfway there, right? Plus, you're making them laugh! I wish I would've had a math teacher like you in school. Plus, you're literary skills are a lot better than who've described them. I'm proud of you. :)

Great post Winston. Keep up the good work~

Ann

mr fong said...

Ann, you should be the teacher,always so encouraging,haha! Thanks for your kind words, I think it is too far above their level, 12-year-olds shouldn't get what I'm talking :)

(Hope they don't catch the satire, LOL!) I still am learning how to catch the attention of pubescent adolescents, and my literary skills need touching up from you, haha! :)

mr fong said...

Btw Ann, thank you for being such a constant encouragement, and I'm glad you enjoyed it, it is dedicated to you for inspiring me to write such little pieces of works, haha ;D

Nicholas Aaron Khoo said...

LOL! I fell on the floor laffing after the first paragraph and end up in hospital liao..

Jos said...

Hi Winston, I always had the same problem as Bobby. In my days at grammar school, the way we were taught maths in The Netherlands was exactly the same. I never saw the point in integrals and asymptotes and equations. They only wanted us to learn the formulas and solve them, never told us why. What is the use of Delta-t I asked, or other questions. I always got the same answer as Bobby did. Only years and years later I discovered the abstractly poetic beauty that can be inside a maths problem. Nowadays my children get a completely different approach. Their maths teacher discusses some 'problem' in every day life with them and then, after they understand the challenge of such problem, he comes and shows them some clever maths thing that can help solve the problem I wish they'd used that same approach on me too. From age 5 to 12 I was doing great at maths, then came algebra and stereometrics and I spent 6 years totally missing the point :)
You seem to be doing a good job in trying to involve you pupils in what you are doing and trying to make maths fun!
Good post, my friend!

WaterLearner said...

Great tips for students taking PSLE or even O & A Levels. I am glad I am over and done with all these. :-)

You can't be more right about answering what that one knows instead of spending too much time on those that one gets stucked.

In life, at times, the same applies as well. We are all borne with different strengths and weaknesses. Much as we hope to remove our weakness, at times it is good to just concentrate on improving our strengths to an even higher level. This might very well make us a better person overall. And through succeeding in what we can do, we will inevitably gain more motivation to face and handle our weaknesses.

Have a Beautiful Sunday, Winston!!

Yong Wen said...

Nice Post :D Perhaps you could get some parents to read the part about scoring via Normal Distribution. That might make them feel better.

Unless they aim for 100, of course.

mr fong said...

Nicholas Aaron Khoo: HAHAHA, I hope I do not see you in ICU..? :)

mr fong said...

Jos: It is important to show why such a working can take place, therefore this is Maths Evolution, haha.

Our system in Singapore is very good at rote learning, but now it is changing... And everyone would complain. We are never happy...

Thank you for your compliments, I do try but I'm not there yet. Thank you! :D

mr fong said...

Hmm, Karen, just now it was Maths Application, now it's Life Application, haha.

You have raised a crucial point- it is important (in trying to eradicate weaknesses) to do what we are strong at, to get Motivation to face weaknesses!

Thank you and have a good weekend! 1.75 hours left, hehe!

mr fong said...

Yong Wen, thanks for your compliments! Schools have been trying to pass it around by presentations, but it does not matter- as long as the kid cannot do it, it does not matter if it is a Transformed Score!

And they will eat up MOE like Megatron over the Transformed scores, haha.

Hope you are well. Btw, all aim for 100 one ;p Most that have smart kids will insist on 100- 'if you lose 2 marks I will cane you at home!!!!!'

Thank you for your views, I appreciate them and hope to see you around here soon! :D

Anti-Mugger said...

hi. i like maths, especially amaths o,o

jerry tan said...

mr fong.

Good job. U have a lot of stuff to say and i got tired of reading. But still, should be good stuff. Haha, your point of view and writing is refreshing.

People should read your site, espeically if they are insomniacs.

~cheers

JesseTheCat said...

Hello Mr Fong,
When I was a youngster in school here in south africa,about 7 years of age, I aksed some questions that my teacher found silly and stupid and I recall that she beat my hands many times in front of the class.For some reason, I brought out the very worst in her ... ha ha, it may be that I was very tall and gangly, and not cute at all.Since then, I had a series of bad maths teachers through the years and have always been a very terrible maths student! Oh, I can count, lol, but I cannot do any formulas or anything awesome.
This post of your rocks...you have a wonderful, humourous and enlightening writing style!
I guess I can learn a lot from your site here, not only about maths but also about really great posts!

J@n!ce said...

I usually will not waste time over tough qns. I will tackle those easier ones first. If time permit, then go back to the difficult one which I think I will better than not score at all. At least just get some sympathy marks for the effort in trying... hehe ;p

Janice Ng

mr fong said...

Anti-mugger, you in the wrong class ah! Haha.

mr fong said...

Jerry: Thanks...I hope you are an insomniac then,hahaha.

mr fong said...

Jesse: Thanks for your insights.. Haha it was unfortunate for you, your teacher is a paed if she only loved cute kids ;p Don't worry, your blog is so Cute liao, haha!

Thank you for your compliments, Mr Fong realizes alot of people have gripes about their maths education leh, haha.Your blog is a very wide spectrum and you make me want to go back, so that's very good.

P.S. Don't worry la, not many people come here and learn maths, haha. Most readers (apart from my dear friends) are parents who want to get tips and questions for practice for Exams, lol!

Thanks Jesse for your very very very kind words.

mr fong said...

Janice: Yeah, at least write something logical that gains you mark. Or can smoke through roughly, haha...

Your tactic is good, for you guarante that you won't waste marks.However many students have just done so these round of exams ;p

Thanks for your good views here, haha...

Jean Chia said...

Winston, this is so funny except that your students will have to sit for the test. :)

I've always loved math and i dont see any difficulties in getting the answer. All you need is passion and practice. I scored A1 in my both Math and Additional Math during my last major exam 8 yrs back! :)

Jean Chia

The Bimbo said...

Oh Oh Oh Bobo went through the PSLE and passed Maths with flying colours! Mr Fong would be proud! :)

Bobo thinks that most parents are so Kiasu they keep asking around for THE formula to calculate the score and they pressurise their kids when they fall a few points short based on their Prelim results.

Bobo's tried so so so hard to explain to people that their kids will be measured against other kids and that the magic number by which the score is attained is different every year based on the cohort... but IT's SO HARD FOR THEM TO UNDERSTAND...

That said... It's sometimes very hard to 12 year olds to gauge if they are able to do a sum or not. When they don't spend enough time thinking about it and skip... they sometimes end up leaving the entire thing blank without really trying any. Generally most of them are not mature enough to understand that it's ok not to know a few. When they meet a few difficult ones, even when they physically move on to the next one, they are already emotionally traumatised...

Maybe they should have section that had all the HOT questions in it... and then a divider that said, Beware! HOT HOT HOT!

mr fong said...

Jean: Haha thank you for being entertained. Didn't know you so good at maths leh. Bish, now I jealous liao, Lol! No la.....So surprised you are good. Good on you :D

Thank you for enjoying it! Haha...

mr fong said...

Bobo Bimbo: HAHAHAHA, hot hot hot. Lol, that was a good good good one! Hahaha...

Yeah, you raised a great point. They physically move on, but they do not mentally go on- they have already stopped there! :(

Congrats on aceing your PSLE maths, haha and without EYM's help you got it! ;p

Btw, appreciate your praise in saying you like the style and are interested by the post. I am gratified. You raise points I enjoy and you go straight to the heart of my post :)

Wah, you comment was 'hot hot hot',haha..

Good night! :)

P.S. Basically, you are right. "the Formula' is actually based on your score that is more than the average, divided by the Range. Just add 10 and you get your score!

Blog Author Ann Clemmons said...

Winston, I just wanted to let you know that I nominated you for the Candied Apple Award. Congrats!

Ann

mr fong said...

Ann, THANK YOU SO MUCH :D

JesseTheCat said...

I am just stopping by to say hello,Mr Fong...I should be posting new content to my blog,but I find it far more interesting to visit all my friends blogs and see whats going on.Reading all the comments is always the most fascinating part of blogging( for me) and I learn all about people from all walks of life.
I hope that your weekend is going great,Mr Fong....and thanks so much for ALL the nice things you had to say about my humble blog.I appreciate your kindness very much :)

Jesse...

mr fong said...

jesse,do not mention the words of thanks! Praise is deserved when one deserves praise.

Anywaym it is true when I praise ur blog,and for you to come over and visit me when i'm so busy (with playing, loL!) empowers and encourages me.Thanks :D